Rent-Try-Buy
With SilverChef |
Apply Now
Commercial Electric vs Gas Steamers: Which Is Right for Your Kitchen?
09
Nov
Commercial electric vs gas steamers is a choice that starts with your menu, not just the energy supply available in your kitchen. Both use steam for cooking, but the appliances can differ considerably in their cooking arrangements, installation requirements and operating costs.
An electric chamber steamer may suit a restaurant preparing dumplings, seafood or vegetables in repeated batches. A gas pot steamer offers a different arrangement that may be more appropriate for cooking with particular pots, baskets or steam racks.
The Benchstar electric steamers and B&S K+ gas pot steamer provide useful examples, although they are not directly equivalent appliances. Before comparing running costs, identify the cooking format you need, check your available utilities and establish how much food the equipment must prepare during peak service.
Electric vs Gas Steamers: How They Work
Electric and gas steamers use different energy sources to produce heat for steam cooking. Electricity or gas alone does not determine the cooking capacity, efficiency or suitability of a particular appliance.
The cooking arrangement is equally relevant. An enclosed chamber steamer and a pot steamer may both prepare dumplings, for example, but they accommodate food differently and need different loading arrangements.
How Commercial Electric Steamers Generate Heat
Commercial electric steamers use electrical heating systems to generate steam. Depending on the appliance, steam may be produced in a boiler or another heating arrangement before entering the cooking chamber.
Electric steamers are available in different sizes and configurations. Their connection requirements also vary, with some models operating from standard single-phase outlets and others requiring higher-amperage single-phase or three-phase connections.
Our Benchstar NP-2SL Electrical Super Steamer has a published 4.4kW rating and requires a 20 amp single-phase supply. Although it uses single-phase electricity, it cannot be connected to an ordinary 10 amp power point.
The model also includes automatic water refilling, wastewater discharge, preset cooking menus and timed operation. These features make it worth assessing for kitchens that need an enclosed steaming chamber, provided its usable cooking capacity suits the menu.
How Commercial Gas Steamers Operate
Commercial gas steamers use heat produced by natural gas or LPG combustion. Some models have enclosed chambers, while others use pot-style arrangements for specific cooking methods.
Our B&S K+ Waterless Pot Steamer (KYCJSF-1) is a gas-powered pot steamer available in natural gas and LPG configurations.
Despite the word waterless in its name, the appliance has a water pot, refill tube and overflow arrangement. The manufacturer’s waterless feature refers to eliminating deck cooling, not operating without water.
A gas steamer requires a compatible fuel supply and appropriate installation. An existing gas connection elsewhere in the kitchen does not establish that the supply can support the selected appliance.
Electric vs Gas Steamers: Key Differences
Neither fuel type is automatically the better choice for every commercial kitchen. The comparison needs to account for cooking format, utility compatibility and how the equipment will be used during service.
| Comparison factor | Commercial electric steamer | Commercial gas steamer |
| Energy source | Electricity | Natural gas or LPG |
| Utility requirements | Suitable electrical supply, circuit and connection | Compatible gas supply with sufficient capacity |
| Cooking formats | Enclosed chambers and other configurations | Enclosed chambers, pot steamers and other configurations |
| Installation | Electrical connection, applicable water and drainage services | Authorised gas installation, applicable water and drainage services |
| Ventilation | Steam removal and any required extraction | Steam removal, combustion ventilation and any required extraction |
| Cooking capacity | Depends on model design, loading and complete cycles | Depends on model design, loading and complete cycles |
| Running costs | Actual electricity consumption and applicable tariff | Actual gas consumption and applicable tariff |
| Maintenance | Heating system, controls, water system and cleaning | Burner, gas components, water system and cleaning |
The distinction between cooking formats matters when comparing the Benchstar NP-2SL with the B&S K+ KYCJSF-1. The Benchstar uses an enclosed chamber, while the B&S model uses a pot arrangement.
Their energy-input ratings cannot establish which appliance cooks more food, which is faster or which has lower operating costs for the same meal. Those questions require comparable information about the food being prepared, loading arrangements and energy consumed during operation.
Check Your Power Supply Before Buying an Electric Steamer
Commercial electric steamers need an electrical connection that matches the manufacturer’s requirements. A power point near the installation area does not, by itself, establish that the circuit can support the appliance.
For higher-powered equipment, ask a licensed electrician to assess the available capacity, circuit protection and connection arrangements before ordering.
Single-Phase Commercial Electric Steamers
The Benchstar NP-2SL has a published 4.4kW rating and requires a 20 amp single-phase electrical supply. Its chamber measures 350 × 548 × 177mm, providing an enclosed space for suitable steaming arrangements.
The appliance includes automatic water refilling, automatic or manual wastewater discharge, four preset menus and timed cooking. Its stackable design is another published feature, although any proposed stacking arrangement needs to be approved for the specific installation.
A standard 10 amp power point is not suitable for its published 20 amp requirement. Changing the plug or using an adaptor does not increase the circuit’s capacity or make an unsuitable connection acceptable.
If your kitchen lacks the appropriate supply, have a licensed electrician establish what work is required. The cost of that work should form part of the purchase comparison.
Three-Phase Commercial Electric Steamers
Our Benchstar NP-4SL Electrical Super Steamer uses three-phase electricity and has a published 6.4kW rating.
Its internal chamber measures 350 × 548 × 377mm, giving it an additional 200mm of height compared with the NP-2SL. This may accommodate taller foods or different compatible tray arrangements, but it does not establish a particular production rate.
Before choosing the NP-4SL, have an electrician confirm that suitable three-phase power is available and that the existing infrastructure has sufficient capacity. The presence of other three-phase equipment does not necessarily mean another appliance can be connected without additional work.
The higher power rating should not be treated as proof of faster cooking or lower energy use per portion. Compare the models’ usable capacity and cooking cycles against your actual workload.
Check Gas Type, Capacity and Installation Requirements
Gas steamers may suit kitchens with compatible gas infrastructure or cooking methods that favour a pot-style arrangement. The available fuel type and the work needed for installation should be established before selecting a model.
Natural Gas vs LPG Connections
The B&S K+ KYCJSF-1 is available in natural gas and LPG configurations. The manufacturer publishes gas-input ratings of 130 MJ/h for natural gas and 98 MJ/h for LPG.
These figures describe the rated gas input for the respective versions. They do not establish total consumption during a trading day or demonstrate that either configuration is cheaper to operate.
Natural gas and LPG are not interchangeable without the appropriate manufacturer-approved arrangements and authorised work. Check the fuel available at your premises and obtain the exact model’s connection requirements before committing to an appliance.
For bottled LPG, also consider the cylinder supply arrangements and the amount of fuel needed during service. A quoted refill price is not directly comparable with a natural-gas tariff until both are expressed in suitable units.
Gas Installation, Ventilation and Compliance
The B&S K+ product information specifies installation by an authorised installer in accordance with the applicable gas installation requirements. Its published features include a gas regulator, flame-failure protection and front access for servicing.
The site assessment may need to cover gas pipe sizing, isolation, combustion air, extraction and maintenance access. Existing infrastructure should not be assumed suitable simply because another gas appliance is operating nearby.
Ventilation also matters for electric equipment. Both electric and gas steamers release steam or vapour into the kitchen environment, depending on their design and operating arrangement.
Queensland’s food-premises design and fit-out guidance requires sufficient natural or mechanical ventilation to remove fumes, smoke, steam and vapours. This is a food-premises requirement, not proof that a particular steamer requires a specific canopy.
Have the proposed installation assessed against the manufacturer’s instructions, applicable local requirements and the ventilation already present in the kitchen.
Which Steamer Suits Your Cooking Requirements?
A steamer should be selected for the foods it can accommodate and the production schedule your kitchen needs to meet.
The most useful starting point is your busiest service period. Identify the number of portions required, the time available and the trays, baskets or vessels used to prepare them.
Electric Chamber Steamers for Dumplings, Seafood and Vegetables
Electric chamber steamers can suit kitchens preparing dumplings, vegetables and seafood in repeated batches. The Benchstar NP-2SL is listed for these applications and offers timed cooking and preset programmes.
Usable chamber capacity depends on the food being prepared, compatible trays, shelf positions and spacing needed for steam circulation.
The chamber’s external dimensions do not tell you how many portions can be cooked. Even internal measurements need to be considered alongside permitted loading arrangements.
For example, a dumpling tray may hold a particular number of portions, while larger buns or seafood may need more vertical clearance. The important measure is the quantity of your menu items that can be cooked in an approved arrangement.
A simple planning calculation is:
Required batches = Peak portions needed ÷ Usable portions per batch
Round the result up to the next whole batch. Then include loading, cooking, unloading and preparation for the next cycle.
Suppose your kitchen needs 120 steamed portions within one hour. If a suitable loading arrangement accommodates 30 portions, you need four batches. If it accommodates 40, you need three.
These figures are hypothetical, not verified output ratings for either Benchstar steamer. The next step is to check complete cycle times and establish whether the required batches can be finished when orders are due.
For more detail on loading and production planning, read our Commercial Vegetable Steamers: Capacity & Buying Guide.
Gas Pot Steamers: Check Vessel Compatibility
The B&S K+ KYCJSF-1 uses a different arrangement from an enclosed chamber steamer. It has a 64-litre stainless steel water pot and a seven-hole perforated steaming plate.
Other published features include a ceramic-lined insulated heating chamber, refill and overflow components, a heavy-duty gas burner and front-access servicing.
The 64-litre specification describes water-pot capacity, not the quantity of food that can be steamed in one batch.
Before choosing this equipment, check the pots, baskets and steam racks used for your menu. Confirm their compatibility, how they will be loaded and how staff will handle food safely during service.
A pot steamer may be preferable where the cooking method calls for that arrangement. The decision should follow the food preparation method rather than an assumption that gas equipment is better suited to high-volume cooking.
Compare Total Costs, Not Just the Equipment Price
A steamer’s purchase price is only part of the initial investment. Electrical upgrades, gas connections, water and wastewater services, ventilation and commissioning may all influence the amount you need to spend before using the appliance.
Compare quotations for equipment that can perform the same required cooking task, rather than judging unrelated models by their purchase prices alone.
Installation Expenses That Can Change Your Budget
An electric steamer may require electrical work if a suitable connection is not already available. Three-phase equipment may involve a more substantial supply assessment or changes to existing infrastructure.
Gas installation costs depend on the fuel type, existing supply, connection requirements and ventilation arrangements. Water supply, drainage and maintenance access also need consideration.
Obtain installation quotes for the specific appliance and location. A useful starting calculation is:
Total initial cost = Equipment price + Delivery + Required installation work + Applicable commissioning costs
Include all relevant plumbing, ventilation and supporting equipment in the installation quotation. A lower equipment price may not produce the lowest overall initial cost if substantial site modifications are necessary.
Estimating Running Costs Without Guessing
Published input ratings can help with preliminary calculations, but they do not establish how much energy an appliance consumes during a complete day of trading.
The basic energy-use calculations are:
Electricity usage cost = Energy consumed (kWh) × Tariff ($/kWh)
Gas usage cost = Energy consumed (MJ) × Tariff ($/MJ)
These calculate energy usage charges, not every part of the operating cost. Fixed supply charges, maintenance and other relevant expenses should be considered separately.
Bottled LPG also needs a unit conversion before its refill price can be used in the gas formula. The South Australian Government’s appliance running-cost guidance, updated on 2 May 2024, uses 49.8 MJ per kilogram of LPG as its conversion factor for estimating the cost per megajoule from a cylinder refill price.
That figure helps convert the fuel price into comparable units. It does not establish the running cost of a particular steamer, and the guidance’s illustrative household tariffs should not be treated as commercial-kitchen prices.
For a meaningful comparison, use the rates that apply to your business and reliable consumption information for a comparable cooking workload. Avoid making a purchase decision from rated kW or MJ/h figures alone.
Which Caterware Steamer Should You Shortlist?
Our commercial steamer range includes electric and gas equipment for different cooking requirements. The appropriate choice depends on what you need to prepare and the installation arrangements available.
Benchstar NP-2SL and NP-4SL Electric Steamers
The Benchstar NP-2SL is worth shortlisting where the kitchen has a suitable 20 amp single-phase connection and its chamber can meet the required cooking schedule.
The Benchstar NP-4SL deserves consideration where three-phase power is available and the additional chamber height offers a practical benefit for compatible trays or food products.
Neither should be chosen solely on its electrical rating. The better candidate is the one that fits your food-loading requirements, service schedule, installation space and available infrastructure.
B&S K+ Gas Waterless Pot Steamer
The B&S K+ Waterless Pot Steamer (KYCJSF-1) is a floor-standing gas appliance with published dimensions of 700 × 840 × 1300mm.
It offers a pot-style cooking arrangement rather than the enclosed chamber configuration of the featured Benchstar models. Its suitability depends on the vessels and preparation methods used in your kitchen.
Consider this model where the pot arrangement meets your cooking needs, the gas supply is compatible and the installation space, ventilation and water services can meet the manufacturer’s requirements.
Commercial Steamer Buying Checklist
Before ordering, confirm the details that could change your equipment choice or installation budget.
- Cooking format: Identify the food, trays, pots or baskets you intend to use and confirm compatibility with the chosen steamer.
- Production requirements: Record the number of portions needed within your busiest service window and check usable batch capacity and complete cycle times.
- Utility compatibility: Confirm the electrical phase and connection requirements or the gas type and supply capacity.
- Installation: Check dimensions, access, water and wastewater arrangements, ventilation, clearances and maintenance requirements.
- Costs: Compare equipment, delivery, required installation work, realistic energy-use estimates and servicing arrangements.
Keep the final choice tied to the cooking task. A technically compatible appliance is still the wrong investment if its loading arrangement cannot meet the demands of your menu.
Commercial Electric vs Gas Steamer FAQs
Is an Electric Commercial Steamer Easier to Install Than a Gas Model?
It may be where a suitable electrical connection already exists, but installation depends on the particular appliance and premises. Higher-powered electric steamers can require electrical upgrades, while gas equipment needs appropriate gas installation and combustion-related assessments. Both may need water services and ventilation.
Is a Gas Commercial Steamer Cheaper to Run Than an Electric Model?
Not necessarily. Running costs depend on actual energy consumption, applicable tariffs and the cooking work performed. Compare equipment using similar production requirements and account separately for supply charges and maintenance.
Does a Waterless Pot Steamer Need Water?
Yes. The B&S K+ KYCJSF-1 has a water pot, refill tube and overflow arrangement. The manufacturer’s waterless feature means deck cooling is not required, rather than steam being produced without water.
Does a Higher Energy-Input Rating Mean Faster Steaming?
No. Input ratings alone do not establish cooking speed or portions per hour. Heating-system design, food quantity, loading arrangements and complete cooking cycles all affect practical production.
Find the Right Commercial Steamer for Your Kitchen
The choice between electric and gas steaming equipment should begin with your menu and the way food is prepared. Once you have identified a suitable cooking format, compare utility requirements, installation costs and usable production capacity.
Browse Caterware’s commercial steamer range to review available models.
If you’re comparing electric chamber steamers with gas pot steamers, contact the Caterware team with your main menu items, intended trays or vessels, available electrical or gas supply, installation measurements and the number of portions needed within a defined service period. We can help you compare the published product information and identify the technical details to confirm before ordering.